and 12k hrs samples regarding the failure morphologies and appearance of these buckled delaminations. This will be highlighted later. 103 104 105 106 107 Initial Strain Range, m/m 0.004 0.006 0.008 0.010 0.012 0.014 Cycles to Failure, Nf 0 hr Conditioning 12k hr Conditioning Cycles to Failure, Nf 103 104 105 106 107 Stress Range, MPa 300 400 500 600 700 800 0 hr Conditioning 12k hr Conditioning Fig. 5-Fatigue life plot based on initial strain range. Fig. 6- Fatigue life plot based on stress range. During fatigue tests, the elastic modulus (E) was checked periodically to determine its degradation or residual value. This was done in both tension and compression. Representative residual compressive modulus data plotted against fatigue cycle are shown in Fig. 7. Results for the 0 hr and 12k hr material are compared for the ±0.4% strain range. The modulus values are normalized with respect to the material’s initial modulus (Eo) at the beginning of the fatigue test. The last cycle plotted for each of the two curves represents the point of complete specimen fracture. As illustrated, both the 0 and 12k hrs HC conditioned materials tended to maintain their initial modulus values over the first several thousand cycles. In general, the modulus of the HC conditioned material tended to degrade earlier. A number of samples experienced a slight “stiffening” trend prior to the measurable degradation, as illustrated by the 0 hr data. This may be a result of the woven fabric “locking-up” with the accumulation of deformation. All observed trends in the modulus response were consistent between tension and compression with the difference being that the compression modulus measurements were generally 2 to 5 % lower for any given sample. In the range of approximately 50,000 cycles and up, the material begins to experience a gradual degradation of modulus that is relatively regular. At the ±0.4 % strain level, the material consistently experienced a minimum of 15 % loss in modulus prior to complete fracture. The following discussion of residual strength and modulus relationships focuses on the ±0.4 % initial strain range fatigue data. RESIDUAL STRENGTH/MODULUS RELATIONSHIPS There are several ways to view the material’s response to the accumulation of the cyclic hygrothermal and mechanical fatigue damage and its ability to tolerate that damage under an ultimate compressive event. Using the 0 and 12k hr HC conditioned material results for the initial strain range of ± 0.4 %, three different permutations of the residual property fatigue data are presented in Figs.8-10. Fig. 8 shows the residual compressive modulus for each specimen as a function of its total number of fatigue cycles. As expected, the residual compressive modulus decreased in magnitude for specimens with a greater accumulation of fatigue cycles. While this trend is consistent with Fig. 7, the degree of degradation is masked in Fig. 8 by significant sample-to-sample modulus variation. Prior to fatigue cycling the compressive modulus of unconditioned material varied 7.6 % from 53.6 to 57.7 GPa and the HC conditioned material varied 5.8 % from 54.4 to 57.6 GPa. This is common to RTM fabricated woven composites, where variations in local fiber orientation and degree of waviness lead to local variations in properties. The average initial compressive modulus of all the samples were 55.4 GPa and 55.6 GPa for the 0 hr and the 12k hr data sets, respectively. This suggests that the
RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy MjM0NDE=