Figure 1: a) Schematic of an Industrial ball mill [5]. b) A typical crack in the rear side of the gear. STRESS ANALYSIS OF THE GEAR The modeling and analysis were performed using the LUSAS software. Figure 2a shows the threedimensional finite element model of the mill, comprising of 8-noded brick elements. Figure 2b is a schematic presentation of the modeling of the charge motion inside the mill, which has been developed using the information presented in reference [3]. In general, the loadings included: charge weight, dynamic loading due to the charge motion, centrifugal forces imposed by partial rotation of the charge, and the driving force imposed by the pinion. The model was restrained in all directions at the location of the front trunnion (the gear side trunnion) while the rear trunnion was free to move only in the axial direction. ANALYSES RESULTS Figure 3 shows the distribution of the maximum principal stress component, S1, in the front face of the gear. The maximum amount of these stresses, 120MPa, occurs between the flat end of the gussets and the flange, at the location of 6 o'clock. The distribution of this stress component conforms to the actual crack paths observed on the cracked gear (see Fig.1b). The distribution of the minimum principle stress component, S3, in the front face of the gear showed a minimum amount of -65MPa, which occurred at the same region, but at a different location, i.e. at 4 o'clock. In fact the deflection of the shell, under the forces imposed by the charge motion, creates bending moments at different locations of the gear flange. These local bending moments cause tensile stresses at one side and compressive stresses at the opposite side of the critical region. As every point at the critical region around the mill, passes through these locations during the mill revolution, a cyclic loading is imposed which can lead to fatigue crack initiation and growth in this region. It is interesting to note that the charge weight and dynamic effects due to the charge motion inside the mill were the main causes of the stress built-up in the gear, and the contribution of the forces imposed by the pinion was only 20 percent. Figures 4 shows the distribution of the maximum principal stress component, S1, in the rear side of the gear. It is clear that the stress levels are generally lower than the front side. However, the existence of two high tensile stress locations can create two loading cycles for every mill rotation. Based on the results of the above analysis and considering the mechanical properties of the gear material shown in table 1, it is clear that the stress levels at the critical regions on the both sides of the gear are sufficient for fatigue crack initiation and growth in these regions. The results obtained from the above
RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy MjM0NDE=