ICF10B

ORAL REFERENCE: ICF100311OR FAILURE ANALYSIS OF THE GIRTH GEAR OF AN INDUSTRIAL BALL MILL M. Mirzaei, A. Razmjoo, A. Pourkamali Department of Mechanical Engineering, T.M.U, Tehran, Iran. ABSTRACT This paper describes the major activities carried out in the process of failure analysis of the girth-gear of an industrial ball mill. Three dimensional finite element modeling and analysis of the mill were performed under various loadings including: charge weight, dynamic loading due to the charge motion, centrifugal forces imposed by partial rotation of the charge, and the driving force imposed by the pinion. The results of the stress analysis conformed to various characteristics of the existing cracks. It was concluded that the charge weight and the dynamic effects due to the charge motion inside the mill were the main causes of the stress built-up in the gear, and the contribution of the forces imposed by the pinion was only 20 percent. Finally, semi-elliptical cracks were modeled and grown through a variable stress field and the crack driving forces were calculated. The calculated crack growth rates were compared with those monitored over a period of 21 months for real cracks. KEYWORDS: Failure Analysis, Girth Gear, Ball Mill, Stress Analysis, Fatigue, Life Assessment, Finite Element. INTRODUCTION The Girth-Gears of industrial Ball-Mills are up to 12 meters in diameter and over 90 tones in weight, with a manufacturing cost exceeding $500,000 (see Fig.1a). These types of gears are expected to have fatigue lives of 20 years and more. In this case history, within the first two years of operation, a few cracks initiated from certain locations between the gussets and the gear flange, and propagated towards the lightening holes, as shown ni Fig.1b. For some cracks, the propagation paths were almost identical on both sides of the gear, while there were several cases of crack propagation on one side. Since the premature occurrence of several similar cracks in certain locations could be interpreted as the possibility of a faulty design, it was decided to perform a complete stress analysis of the mill using the finite element method. In similar analyses reported in the literature the main charge with a flat surface has been considered as a major source of loading [1,2]. Accordingly, due to the symmetry of geometry and loading, only one half of the mill has been analyzed. In our analysis we considered various sources of loadings including the charge weight with a slanted surface, which required a complete 3-D modeling and analysis. The analysis results clearly revealed the cause of failure, i.e., high stress built-up in specific locations adjacent to the gear flange, and conformed to various characteristics of the existing cracks, including their propagation paths. This paper also describes the assessment of the remaining life of the gear through modeling of crack growth in the high-stress region. In these analyses, semi-elliptical cracks were modeled and grown through a variable stress field, and the crack driving forces were calculated. The calculated crack growth rates were compared with those monitored over a period of 21 months for real cracks.

RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy MjM0NDE=